Comments on the R3 Zoning District Update (Item 6.3)

Re: Agenda Item 6.3

Dear Mayor Ramos and Council Members:

We thank everyone who has worked on this seven-year project, and we are excited to see this move from drafting to implementation. We appreciate that some of our previous requests were incorporated, like increasing retail opportunities, allowing features like arcades to project into setbacks, and granting height exceptions for community benefits. We do have some comments we believe would help further the project’s goals to create (and encourage) opportunities for diverse unit types and produce better design. At the October 7 EPC hearing, Commissioner Subramanian recommended several of the changes below (parking on small lots, the color-change rule, the transition-area standards and R2 owner occupancy), and Chair Nuñez supported the parking, green wall and color-change items. The staff report’s summary of the EPC recommendation mentions only the delivery and drop-off areas.

Feasibility on Small Lots

We thank staff for improving feasibility on small sites, as they make up 61% of R3 by lot count and 23% by area. We recommend three further changes for small lots to ensure better use of their limited space: reducing the parking minimum for ≥2BD from 1.5 to 1 in 36.32.50(c), removing barriers to placing parking in front, and clarifying the side setback override.

Each additional parking spot demands more ground floor for it and the driveway, taking away space from the residence and greenspace. Small lots have little breathing room already, so a reduced parking minimum may be what it takes to fully unlock their capability.

The ordinance keeps surface parking 40 to 50 feet back from the front lot line, depending on the zone, and allows parking closer to the street only inside a building that keeps a habitable frontage (36.11.05(e)(1)(b) and 36.11.30). We understand the goal is a friendlier street frontage. On a lot under 70 feet wide, that leaves a builder two options: put a garage in the ground floor, or run a driveway the depth of the lot to reach parking behind the building. We ask that small lots also be allowed surface parking inside the front parking setback, which would leave more of the lot for homes and a usable backyard.

The reduced side setback for small lots in 36.11.05(d)(2) seems a bit out of place, relative to where most setbacks are defined. It is especially confusing for R3-B (Table 36.11.10.G), which has a setback for small lots that is in conflict. We also note that the Starter Home Revitalization Act, which is likely going to be the path for projects on these lots, has its own override for side setbacks of four feet, same as SB9.

Massing Transitions and Modular Housing

We are pleased to see that massing transition thresholds were raised and alternative transition methods that do not significantly impact the building’s physical design are offered. However, 36.17.25(c)(5)(c) says a facade “shall not change color without a plane change of at least four (4) inches or a material change.” We believe this harms its utility, especially for modular projects where such requests may not align with large-batch production. The city has supported modularization for greater construction productivity and cost savings. Separately from modularization concerns, asking for such requirements would also impose general soft (architectural) and hard costs for something that does not seem to provide commensurate benefits for the public nor the new residents.

We would further like clarification on how architectural devices and ornamentation are meant to be counted. As written, a four-story building over 120 feet long that uses this option has to switch from one set of ornamentation to another partway along the facade, and a longer building has to switch more than once. Given that the primary function of this section is aesthetic, we should not be encouraging developers to avoid basic principles of pattern and symmetry in favor of combining a predetermined number of ornamentation transitions. A coherent, repeated ornamentation should be allowed to satisfy the requirement.

Avoiding Downzoning

We acknowledge the work to comply with the Housing Crisis Act. Attachment 17 maps the sites where the existing buildings already exceed the maximum density of their proposed zone. Zoning a site to allow fewer homes than are already there amounts to a downzoning of that site, regardless of what the zoning for that site previously was. We believe it is simpler to place each of those sites in the R3 or R4 zone that fits what is built there. One example raised at EPC is 2747 Del Medio Court, where the owner’s representative said 85 apartments stand on a site whose proposed R3-B zoning allows 78, with R4 on two sides. Such sites already demonstrate the character and capability of a higher tier, and rezoning them allows additions and renovations to be reviewed with more relevant standards than under the nonconforming amendments. Zoning changes in a time of severe housing need should ratchet higher, not lower. If the EIR limits what can change at this hearing, we ask Council to direct staff to return with these rezonings.

R2 Density

The exact wording of Housing Element Program 1.3(h) is “[For R2], upzone to either allow density greater than typical R1 properties under SB9, (at least four units per typical parcel, plus ADUs) or integrate the sites into the R3 zone.” In our perspective, this means to allow projects like fourplexes or anything else allowed under a R-12 General Plan designation, rather than strictly limiting it to DUOs. As such, we recommend that City revisit this in future reviews to accommodate such building types to ensure it indeed is feasible to develop projects in R2 that are denser than R1. The ordinance adds one ADU in R2, for five units on an existing lot (36.13.35(b)). In the near term, the City could allow more ADUs or JADUs than that.

SB9 itself is only binding in R1; as such, there are various restrictions imposed by SB9 that do not apply and should not apply to R2. In particular, we believe that the owner occupancy restriction in 36.13.75 can be lifted in R2 as that is a known deterrent. Restriction on primary unit sale in 36.13.30 may also be unneeded as the zone already allows for duplexes. Ellis Act and demolition protections may also be replaced by their SB330 equivalents so development can occur without needing units to be vacant for years.

Additional analysis may be necessary to determine if common building layouts in R2 would work with DUOs, in particular the driveway requirements and front setback requirements in echoes of our earlier comments. Larger unit sizes in 36.13.45(b) may also be more appropriate in R2.

Prison-Wall Transition Areas

We are concerned about the design standards in 36.11.40(c), which apply within 50 feet of an R1 or R2 parcel to buildings taller than three stories. They prohibit balconies facing the R1 or R2 lot, cap glazing at 10 percent of each upper-story wall with egress windows counted against the cap, and require a green wall over half of the wall unless tall trees are planted along the property line. Limiting the amount of windowed surface on a side of a property inherently restricts air circulation and natural light for affected units, reducing residents’ quality of life and increasing energy use for HVAC and lighting. Developers wanting a normal amount and size of windows without retreating from the transition area would have to reshape walls to point windows back into the development, which adds architectural complexity and makes modularization difficult. Additionally, green walls are not easy to maintain, and if handled poorly may lead to water damage. We ask Council to remove the glazing cap and the green wall requirement and rely on the tree planting that 36.11.40(c)(3) already allows as an alternative. Such standards demonstrate a bias towards households in single-family over households in multi-family as such regulations don’t exist (and shouldn’t exist) between neighboring R3/R4 buildings; this goes against the spirit of a Community for All.

All in all, we look forward to a Mountain View more ready to develop the housing suppressed by decades of stasis, and we hope the City continues to find ways to improve our housing situation.

Thank you for your consideration.
David Watson, on behalf of Mountain View YIMBY