Re: Agenda Item 6.4
Dear Mayor Ramos and Council Members,
Mountain View YIMBY would like to echo the caution we gave to the Council Finance Committee in January on charging park fees on new housing. The City is navigating a post-Sheetz environment where laws like the Quimby Act and Mitigation Fee Act are not safe-harbors as they once were, as Los Altos is seeing with their ongoing lawsuit. We also remind Council that if fees make projects infeasible, then the City would sacrifice the potential revenue from property tax reassessments for no benefit.
Park Land Dedication
We appreciate that staff is aiming to codify the “roughly proportional” criteria with a cap maintaining the existing space-per-person metric. The cap should be clarified to be the lower of the two specified standards. We further recommend an absolute dollar amount cap as Housing Element Program 1.8 specifies to “reduce the monetary parkland in-lieu fee payment by at least 20%, on average” and the proposed metric cap rises with the cost of land. The staff report is also silent on whether there is indeed a guaranteed 20% reduction.
The revised language also does not seem to comply with ministerial review as it specifies discretion on how to accept a dedication as either land, money, or a mix.
Park and Recreation Facilities Fee
We believe the new Fee should contain the same credit opportunities as under the Park Land Dedication rather than only allowing direct land donations to the city, for ease in understanding for developers as well as city reviewers. The fee should also be limited to spending on the Project List in 41.51(e) rather than be used anywhere else in 41.51(d)’s current language, if the intent is to truly address the demands of new residents.
We recommend the fee, this or the in-lieu, be collected at issuance of certificate of occupancy, assessed at time of first building permit issuance. Density bonus and other projects are already required to do so in SB 937 (Gov Code 66007), and the orphan “Certificate of Occupancy” definition in 41.51(b) implies something similar was to be done. Charging money at the project’s tightest financial point, with high-interest construction loans but no income, makes the project much riskier; the fee would be refunded anyway if the project fails.
Credits
We question the decision to exclude deed-restricted units above the city’s inclusionary requirements from the affordable housing exemption. The city wants affordable units, and this unnecessarily penalizes more of them in addition to adding more complexity to project review.
Housing Element Program 1.8 specifies “relaxing regulations on the size and type of POPAs and/or allowing parkland credit for new pedestrian connections and trails”, but the proposed changes only include the latter without explanation. We believe the eligibility criteria of size and dimensions should be reduced to apply POPA credit to smaller lots, and the exclusion of city-mandated open space should be revisited.
Thank you for your consideration.
Isaac Stone, on behalf of Mountain View YIMBY