Dear Environmental Planning Commissioners,
We thank everyone who has worked on this seven-year project, and we are excited to see this move from drafting to implementation. We appreciate that some of our previous requests, like increasing retail opportunities, allowing features like arcades to project into setbacks, and granting height exceptions for community benefits, were incorporated. We do have some comments we believe would help further its goals to create (and encourage) opportunities for diverse unit types and produce better design.
Parking on Small Lots
We thank staff for improving feasibility on small sites, as they make up 61% of R3 by lot count and 23% by area. We recommend two further changes to ensure better use of their limited physical dimensions: reducing the parking minimum for two-bedrooms-and-larger from 1.5 to 1 in 36.32.50(c) and removing/reducing the minimum front parking setback.
Each additional parking spot demands more ground floor both for it and the driveway, taking away space from the residence and any green space. Small lots leave little breathing room, so a reduced parking minimum may be what it takes to fully unlock their capability. We also note that, aside from rowhouses, no other parking minimum is determined by the number of bedrooms in a unit, even if those units are much bigger.
We recognize the reason for a large minimum front parking setback of >40’ may be to encourage friendlier public spaces over immediate parking access. While this goal can encourage a more vibrant streetscape, it is a poor fit for development of lots under 70 feet in width, which do not have substantial width to allocate to a driveway to access the rear of the property. Additionally, since these lots are often longer than they are wide, a substantial portion of the property would need to be taken up by the driveway to access the rear parking area. We thus believe that the city should allow developers of small lots the choice of placing parking in the front of the property. In addition to increasing the developability of smaller R3 lots, the resulting developed lots would have less area allocated to impermeable driveways and more area allocated to green space in the back yard, which future residents would appreciate.
Massing Transitions and Modular Housing
We are pleased to see that massing transition thresholds were raised and alternative transition methods that do not significantly impact the building’s physical design are offered.
However, 36.17.25(c)(7)(C) specifies that the color change is only a valid transition if there’s “a plane change of at least four inches or a material change.” We believe this restricts its usefulness, especially for modular projects where such requests may not align with their focus on large-scale standardization. The city has previously supported the concept of modularization to achieve greater construction productivity and cost savings.
We would further like clarification on how architectural devices and ornamentation counts as a transition; it would seem odd that >200’-long buildings would need three different ornamentation styles in order to comply. Given that the primary function of massing breaks is aesthetic, we should not be encouraging developers to avoid basic principles of pattern and symmetry in favor of arbitrarily combining a predetermined number of transition types.
Avoiding Downzoning
We acknowledge the work to comply with the Housing Crisis Act. However, we believe it is simpler for the residential parcels marked for downzoning to be converted to their more compatible R3 zone. Such sites already demonstrate the character and capability of a higher tier, and this allows additions and renovations to be reviewed with more tailored, clearer standards than those under the nonconforming provisions. Zoning changes, especially in a time of high housing demand, should ratchet higher, not lower.
R2 Density
The exact wording of Housing Element Program 1.3(h) is “[For R2], upzone to either allow density greater than typical R1 properties under SB9, (at least four units per typical parcel, plus ADUs) or integrate the sites into the R3 zone." In our perspective, this means to allow projects like fourplexes or anything else allowed under a R-12 General Plan designation, rather than strictly limiting it to DUOs. As such, we recommend that City revisit this in future reviews to accommodate such building types to ensure it indeed is feasible to develop projects in R2 that are denser than R1. In the near term, the City could consider allowing more ADUs or JADUs.
SB9 itself only applies to R1; as such, there are various restrictions imposed by SB9 that do not apply and should not apply to R2. In particular, we believe that the owner occupancy restriction in 36.13.75 can be lifted in R2 as that is a known deterrent. Restriction on primary unit sale in 36.13.30 may also be unneeded as the zone already allows for duplexes. Ellis Act and demolition protections may also be replaced by their SB330 equivalents so development can occur without needing units to be vacant for years.
Additional analysis may be necessary to determine if common building layouts in R2 would work with DUOs, in particular the driveway requirements and front setback requirements in echoes of our earlier comments. Larger unit sizes in 36.13.45(b) may also be more appropriate in R2.
Prison-Wall Transition Areas
We are concerned about the zoning transition area requirements that limit windows and open air access and impose an expensive green barrier. Limiting the amount of windowed surface on a side of a property inherently restricts air circulation and natural light for affected units, reducing residents’ quality of life and increasing energy use for HVAC and lighting. Rather than pointing windows out of the development, where residents can have views of the surrounding area (e.g., of the mountains), developers will be forced to place windows into the development and towards other residents’ windows, resulting in less privacy. Additionally green walls are not easy to maintain, and if handled poorly may lead to water intrusion issues. Such standards demonstrate a bias towards households in single-family over households in multi-family as such regulations don’t exist (and shouldn’t exist) between neighboring R3/R4 buildings; this goes against the spirit of a Community for All.
All in all, we look forward to a Mountain View more ready to develop the housing suppressed by decades of stasis, and we hope the City continues to find ways to improve our housing situation.
Thank you for your consideration.
Pardis Beikzadeh, on behalf of Mountain View YIMBY