Dear Chair Ramos & Committee Members,
Mountain View YIMBY would like the city to take caution as it continues to explore how to fund parks. We do support neighborhood amenities, but we should not depend mainly on taxing new housing to pay for amenities broadly used by everyone, especially in a housing shortage.
The Housing Element states the park land dedication requirement is the second-most costly constraint the city imposes, just behind the below-market-rate requirement and significantly ahead of anything else. It is so expensive that developers have been deliberately building apartments instead of condominiums in order to avoid the fee, as seen with 749 W El Camino Real and the disputes over 881 Castro Street. Having fees scaled per-unit also encourages developers to build bigger but less-dense projects, which adversely impacts both city revenue and housing production (see developer comments on R3). Making all fees proportional to floor area, rather than per-unit, could address these unintended impacts.
The staff memo mentions outreach to the development community, yet it omits what they said. We would like a written summary of the discussion or how it shaped the recommendation; otherwise such outreach is pointless.
The memo is also silent on the legality of the existing “single-lot” dedication requirement, which is supported neither under the Quimby Act (which applies only to subdivisions) nor the Mitigation Fee Act (city has annually stated noncompliance). This leaves projects in ambiguity and non-uninformity, where a project like 749 W ECR can avoid the fee, yet projects entitled prior are not eligible for refunds. We’re not sure whether projects currently under review have been made aware of the situation, given the lack of information on the city website.
The Quimby Act specifies a land dedication “not to exceed” 3 acres per 1000 residents; we would like the city to provide a justification for the service standard beyond citing tradition or seeking the maximum legal safe harbor. The city should look at existing park usage rates. We further note that quality of parks is as important as quantity; the City has used the quantity standard as a shortcut to avoid important discussions of what should be in the parks, only broached recently in the Parks and Recreation Strategic Plan work.
We would like greater transparency in how the land and improvement appraisal was conducted. A criticism of the existing park fee was that the valuation assumed the city was competing with developers for the same residential land, which was more of a legal fiction than reality that AB 1218 has further complicated. The city should provide the costs of the most recent park land acquisitions and improvement projects for context.
The city should also provide an analysis of the long-term effects of discouraging development on city finances—a high up-front park fee will discourage additional development, negatively impacting future city revenues for the lifetime of the project.
The city should pay attention to the lawsuit against Los Altos on their impact fees, including their park land fee (24CV447754). As the staff memo specifies, Sheetz has opened up litigation risk significantly. That lawsuit also points out that the city, under AB 602, must adopt a capital improvement plan as a part of any nexus study.
Thank you for the opportunity to comment,
James Kuszmaul, on behalf of MV YIMBY